There are many misconceptions and stereotypes about the Amish that are often perpetuated in popular culture.
Whether you’re interested in learning more about the Amish out of curiosity or interacting with them more respectfully and thoughtfully, this guide will provide valuable insights and dispel some common myths.
Let’s dive in and explore the truth about the Amish.
10 Common Misconceptions About the Amish
1. The Amish Reject All Modern Technology [FALSE]
While the Amish do avoid certain technologies that they believe will erode their community’s values, they do use some modern technology. For example, they sometimes use electricity and certain medical devices.
To ensure that their way of life is not disrupted, the Amish have established specific guidelines for technology use. These rules outline what types of technology are acceptable and in what situations they can be used.
Amish church leaders frequently hold meetings to discuss and determine which new technologies the community should embrace.
The use of technology varies by community. For example, Amish individuals running their own businesses are allowed to use electricity and computers at the office.
2. The Amish Are Uneducated [FALSE]
The Amish value education and have their own schools. They focus on practical skills such as reading, writing, and arithmetic.
While they may not pursue higher education, many Amish are knowledgeable and skilled in their chosen trades. Farming, woodworking, and homemaking are more important to them than pursuing formal higher education.
3. The Amish Are Anti-Social and Won’t Talk to Outsiders [FALSE]
While the Amish value their community and way of life, they do interact with the outside world for business, medical care, and other essential needs.
Some Amish even work outside of the community or run businesses that cater to tourists. Amish businesses are highly successful.
The Amish are welcoming to outsiders who show respect for their beliefs and way of life. They are friendly and will gladly talk to outsiders.
As a matter of fact, many Amish communities depend on outside visitors for income.
4. The Amish Practice Arranged Marriages [FALSE]
Amish families may introduce their children to potential partners, but the decision to marry is ultimately up to the individuals.
Amish marriages are not arranged. They are based on shared values, beliefs, and lifestyle, rather than external factors like wealth or status.
Speaking on marriages, due to their limited gene pool, the Amish make active efforts to prevent genetic relatedness and inbreeding.
5. The Amish Are All the Same [FALSE]
The Amish are not all the same. There is some variation among different communities and even within families.
The Amish community comprises multiple subgroups with differing beliefs and rules concerning technology usage.
Some Amish communities may have stricter rules or traditions than others. At the same time, individuals may interpret and apply those rules differently.
For example, the Beachy Amish allow the ownership and use of motorized vehicles. On the other hand, the Swartzentruber Amish strictly forbid riding in cars except in cases of emergency.
6. The Amish Don’t Pay Taxes [FALSE]
Like all US. citizens, the Amish are required to pay local, state, and federal taxes. However, they may be exempt from certain taxes, such as Social Security and Medicare, due to their religious beliefs.
They also pay public school taxes although their children don’t go to public schools. Amish kids attend one-room Amish-run schools.
7. The Amish Are Opposed to Healthcare [FALSE]
The Amish are not opposed to healthcare. In fact, they value healthcare and have their own unique approach to it.
While they may reject some aspects of modern medicine, such as health insurance and elective procedures, they see doctors and go to the hospital when they’re ill or have a medical emergency.
8. The Amish Instantly Shun Those Who Stray Out From the Ordnung [FALSE]
The practice of shunning is not at all common among the Amish. A member is shunned after repeated attempts to encourage them to rejoin the community or to cease the behaviors that led to their punishment.
As most Amish communities are small, they cannot easily afford to lose members, unless it is the last resort.
9. Amish Women Have Very Few Rights [FALSE]
It is a misconception that Amish women have very few rights. While the Amish rely on a patriarchal community structure with men typically serving as community and household leaders, women hold significant roles and responsibilities.
Amish women are responsible for managing households which typically involve tasks such as cooking, cleaning, and childcare. They also play a significant role in generating income for the household.
Amish women play important roles in the community. They help organize events and provide support to those in need.
They are actively involved in decision-making processes in their families and communities. They are consulted and their opinions are valued.
Women are also allowed to own property and can inherit from their parents.
While Amish women dress modestly and often wear head coverings, this is a religious tradition rather than a sign of oppression.
10. The Amish Eat Only Organic Food [FALSE]
The Amish do not exclusively eat organic food. While many Amish families do grow their own food using traditional farming methods, others may purchase food from supermarkets that may or may not be organic.
Additionally, some Amish families may choose to use conventional farming methods to increase their crop yields or to save time and labor.
Conclusion
It’s important to approach the Amish with an open mind and a willingness to learn more about them. Don’t rely on stereotypes and misconceptions.
By learning more about their beliefs and traditions, we can develop a deeper understanding and appreciation for this unique community.